Are Consumers That Dumb? The Wall Street Journal Thinks We Are

January 6, 2009

An inflammatory article appeared last week in the Wall Street Journal called “The Touch that Doesn’t Heal .” It deserves a thorough reading and some impassioned letters to the editor. The article, written by Steve Salerno, claims that “Americans pay billions for alternative medicine—with nothing to show for it.”

The article categorizes the entire practice of integrative medicine as “bypassing the customary peer review, controlled studies and other hallmarks of sound medicine.” That is not accurate. Moreover, Mr. Salerno points to vested interests in complementary and alternative medicine pushing their agendas and filling their pocketbooks, while failing to mention that the vested interests of pharmaceutical drug makers and medical device manufacturers have had a profound negative influence on medical school education, research, medical journal publication, and clinical practice standard-of-care.

Mr. Salerno, who authored the book Sham: How the Self-Help Movement Made America Helpless and blogs at www.shamblog.com, makes a valid point that a substantial percentage of Americans pay out of their own pockets to use complementary and alternative therapies. However, he fails to acknowledge the reason they do so—because the current allopathic medical system often fails them when they face chronic disease.

An overwhelming 78% of our nation’s healthcare dollars go to the treatment of chronic disease, according to the May 2005 issue of the Journal of the American Medical Association. This makes those with chronic health challenges especially vulnerable to unscrupulous businesses and practitioners, whether they are allopathic or alternative in their approach, eager to sell their wares and services. Even government sources of educational medical literature are skewed by vested interests.
We can all agree the system is broken. The American consumer lacks objective scientific data on which to base healthcare decisions, and when studies are done, they are frequently so skewed by vested interests that one doesn’t know whom to trust. The current system pushes pills and procedures while time-tested modalities like homeopathy, acupuncture, herbs and other therapies are ignored. We waste billions of dollars and fail to address lifestyle education, which could dramatically reduce the financial toll on our nation’s healthcare.

One response to “Are Consumers That Dumb? The Wall Street Journal Thinks We Are”

  1. Heath Watts says:

    Please don’t include homeopathy among viable treatment modalities. Homeopathy involves prescribing pure water or fillers to patients with zero percent active ingredient. For example, if I’m having trouble sleeping, a homeopath would prescribe a solution that contains caffeine, since they believe that like treats like, and if I am having trouble sleeping, then I need a stimulant. This is, of course pure nonsense, and would render their patients much worse for wear, if their treatment actually contained caffeine. The treatment, in fact contains zero percent caffeine and just fillers (in pill form) or water (in liquid form). Homeopathic medicine is a hoax, and I don’t want any of my tax dollars going to support it. I do agree that alternative medicine treatments may have some merit, but unless they can withstand scientific evaluation that shows their efficacy, then they are not valid treatments. Homeopathic treatments do not help the patient, but they do make homeopaths and companies that produce their snake oil very rich.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *