A renewed White House push to define ultra-processed foods could advance MAHA’s promise of a healthier food supply. But could Big Food derail efforts for its own benefit? Action Alert!
Listen to the audio version of this article:
THE TOPLINE
- The White House is renewing its push to define ultra-processed foods that CDC says comprise 55% of all calories consumed in the US. The definition could shape food labeling, school meals, and dietary guidance. ANH is concerned about food industry influence shaping the policy.
- Studies link higher consumption of ultra-processed foods to obesity, type 2 diabetes, and other adverse outcomes. Children and adolescents consume the highest proportion.
- The definition should account for how foods are made and their full composition, including for products such as cultivated meat and precision-fermented ingredients. ANH also calls on Congress to consider updating federal food safety law to address harms that may emerge with repeated consumption.
Big Food has a powerful incentive to help Washington define ultra-processed food. It will try its best to ensure as many of its own products as possible escape the definition.
That is the danger as the Trump administration renews its push to establish a federal definition of ultra-processed foods (UPFs).
For Americans who want healthier food, this is a critical opening, but we must approach it with clear eyes. MAHA has been an important voice within the administration, but Big Food interests have won a number of important battles.
The question is whether the administration will confront the problems with industrially manufactured food—including the new wave of ‘GMO 2.0’ (gene-edited) products—or simply help companies repackage them.
Industry Influence Remains the Central Test
As ANH recently argued, having MAHA allies in government has not eliminated the influence of industries whose interests conflict with meaningful reform.
The pesticide fights offer a warning. The administration’s executive order prioritizing glyphosate stock, alongside congressional efforts to shield pesticide manufacturers from liability, exposed the tension between promises to reduce toxic exposures and policies favoring chemical companies. We’ve also seen significant rollbacks of PFAS “forever chemical” safeguards.
The same scrutiny belongs in the UPF debate. A federal definition could shape future labeling, school food policies, research, and dietary advice. Companies have much to gain from keeping their products outside its reach.
The Evidence Warrants Action
Federal nutrition policy has already moved far too cautiously. As ANH reported during development of the 2025 Dietary Guidelines, the advisory process missed an opportunity to give Americans clear direction on ultra-processed foods.
The committee’s systematic review recognized associations between higher UPF consumption and greater body fat and overweight or obesity in children and adults. Yet these federal nutrition “experts” declined to offer meaningful guidance on ultra-processed foods, citing supposedly “limited” evidence.
Really? A 2024 BMJ umbrella review linked greater UPF exposure with numerous adverse outcomes, including type 2 diabetes, cardiovascular mortality, obesity, and depression. In a small, tightly controlled NIH feeding trial, participants ate roughly 500 additional calories a day on an ultra-processed diet and gained about two pounds over two weeks. They lost about two pounds during the minimally processed diet period.
We do not need every biological mechanism resolved before helping families reduce their reliance on these foods. We need a definition that allows individuals and families to make healthier choices at the grocery store.
The Loophole in Healthy Ultra-Processed Food
As ANH has explained, proposals to exempt supposedly “healthy” UPFs must be opposed. A product should not receive a clean bill of health simply because it meets selected nutrient thresholds.
This matters especially for cultivated meat, precision-fermented ingredients, gene-edited foods, and products assembled through 3D printing. Their proponents want to convince us that, although they are ultra-processed, they are healthy and environmentally friendly. But we know that food is more than a collection of protein, fat, carbohydrates, and added vitamins. Its physical structure—the food matrix—and the wider mixture of compounds surrounding those nutrients help determine how it behaves in the body. To determine the health impact of a food, we have to look at the overall nutrient profile within which these nutrients are found, not just the presence of a few isolated nutrients.
And what about the dozens of previously unknown compounds that are showing up in lab-grown, ‘synbio’ or so-called ‘precision fermentation’ food products that are being marketed as eco-friendly, alternatives to natural foods?
The concern is that a narrow UPF definition could look the other way on these foods while rewarding manufacturers for matching a few familiar nutrients.
Bringing Food Law into the Modern Food Supply
A useful starting point is already embedded in federal law: food should not be injurious to health.
Section 402 of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act addresses adulterated food. It covers spoiled or filthy food, but it also includes poisonous or deleterious substances that may make food harmful, subject to specific statutory conditions. The law has never been limited to food that looks or smells rotten.
Lawmakers should consider how this framework addresses modern formulations and harm that may emerge through repeated consumption of UPFs. A product can remain shelf-stable and microbiologically clean while raising serious questions about its long-term effects. Congress should consider targeted updates to Section 402 that address modern food production and chronic health risks.
A Definition That Serves Consumers
An effective approach would make processing and composition more transparent, resist exemptions based on a handful of nutrients, and require meaningful answers about novel products. It would preserve informed choice while holding manufacturers accountable for harmful food.
Americans were promised a healthier food supply. They should not have to settle for a new definition that lets Big Food carry on as before.
Action Alert!